Analysis & stories
Bayer Leverkusen Bundesliga top four: fifth place, an empty clinch column, and four clubs with the same row
As of the September 21 update Leverkusen are fifth on 7 points, one place outside the four European spots, and both the clinch column and the tragic column on their row are empty. The two blanks mean opposite things and come from the same rule about level finishes. Four other clubs return the identical six figures. Here is what each figure says and what none of them says yet.
Clinch Desk · Sun, Sep 20
Bayer Leverkusen can finish this Bundesliga season on 97 points. The total that guarantees a top four place is 98. That one point is the whole reason the clinch column on their row is blank, and there is no 35th match to find it in.
Everything below is as of the September 21 update, which covers 36 of the season's 306 matches. All 18 clubs have played four and have 30 left. Leverkusen's most recent result is a 2-0 home win over RB Leipzig on September 20, and the last matches in the feed are Paderborn 3-1 Hoffenheim and Schalke 0-0 Elversberg on September 21.
Three clubs in the division carry a top four clinch line, and each one adds up to the same total. Borussia Dortmund lead on 12 points with a line of 86. Bayern Munich and SC Freiburg are on 10 with a line of 88. Twelve plus 86 is 98. Ten plus 88 is 98. That 98 is the bar: reach it and no combination of other results can push you out of the top four. The other 15 clubs, Leverkusen included, cannot reach it at all.
The bar sits at 98 rather than 97 because a rival who can finish exactly level counts as a threat. Leverkusen are on 7 points with 30 matches and 90 points still to play for, so their ceiling is 97. Four clubs can reach exactly 97 as well, and all four are level with Leverkusen on 7 right now: FC Augsburg, Mainz 05, SV Elversberg and Werder Bremen. Above them, Dortmund can reach 102 and Bayern and Freiburg 100. Seven rivals able to finish at or above 97 is not a guarantee of anything, so the cell stays empty.
The tragic column on Leverkusen's row is blank too, and it means the opposite thing. Lose all 30 remaining matches and Leverkusen finish on 7 points. Being eliminated from the top four requires four clubs certain to be strictly above you, and only three clubs are above 7 points today: Dortmund on 12, Bayern and Freiburg on 10. The four clubs sitting level on 7 cannot eliminate Leverkusen by drawing level with them. A level finish does not complete an elimination on the way down and does not complete a clinch on the way up. That is one rule applied at both ends.
Leverkusen are not alone in this. Augsburg, Mainz, Elversberg and Bremen return exactly the same six scenario figures: no top four clinch line, no top four tragic number, no title clinch line, a title tragic number of 29, a safety line of 85, and no relegation tragic number. Their reachable ranges match too. The table still orders those five clubs, from Augsburg in 4th down to Bremen in 8th, and it does that on goals. Leverkusen have scored 10 and conceded 5, Augsburg 11 and 6, Mainz 10 and 6, Elversberg 8 and 7, Bremen 8 and 8. None of that enters the calculation.
Two of the six figures do carry a number. The safety line is 85: collect 85 of the 90 points still available and the two relegation places are cleared whatever anyone else does. Seven plus 85 is 92, one above the 91 that Union Berlin can still reach and two above Mönchengladbach's 90. Those are the only two clubs Leverkusen can be certain of finishing above, which is where the bar comes from. The title tragic number is 29: lose 29 of the 30 and the best Leverkusen can finish on is 10, below the 12 Dortmund have already banked. The reachable range reads 1st to 18th, and it reads that for all 18 clubs, so it is not telling anyone anything yet.
None of these columns move for 19 days. The next fixtures in the feed are on October 10, when Leverkusen go to Mainz. That is a meeting of two clubs with identical scenario rows: 7 points each, both columns blank, the same safety line of 85, the same title tragic number of 29. The same day brings Augsburg against Bayern Munich and Dortmund against Werder Bremen, two of the three fixtures involving a club that holds a top four line. Stuttgart at Paderborn, Elversberg at Union Berlin and Hamburg at Hoffenheim complete October 10, and October 11 has Gladbach at Köln and Frankfurt at Leipzig. SC Freiburg, the third club with a line, close the nine-match round at home to Schalke on October 12. The dates are Korean time.
Correction, September 29: An earlier version said SC Freiburg did not appear among the next fixtures and that only two fixtures involved a club with a top four line. Freiburg host Schalke on October 12, the ninth match of the round, which makes three. The paragraph above now includes it. None of the clinch or tragic numbers changed.
How to read these figures. A clinch line is the minimum a club must still collect for a place to be guaranteed even if every rival wins everything they have left. A tragic number is the number of further defeats after which that outcome is impossible even if the club wins everything else and no rival takes another point. A reachable range is the highest and lowest finish still arithmetically open. A finish exactly level on points is never treated as decisive: it does not complete a clinch and it does not complete an elimination, so our clinch marker can trail an official confirmation. Goal difference, head to head fixtures and the official tiebreakers are all outside the calculation. Leverkusen's own page is at and Mainz at. The table is at, the remaining fixtures at, the qualification and relegation rules at, every club's lines at, the method at, and takes a run of results and shows you where the bar moves.
Related